Dear Santa: I can explain...

No need to explain. Just take 10% your holiday purchase by 12/10 with HOLIDAY21

SHOP NOW

Engagement & Wedding

Celebrate love with these elegant cookies. Pick one of our designs, send us your own or have us design something to celebrate this special day.

See More

Logo Cookies

Choose the details you'd like and these made-from-scratch shortbread cookies will arrive exactly how you imagined. They make great promotional items, corporate gifts, or favors for any special occasion. We can even make these cookies based on your business card.

See More

Edible Storybook Cupcake Toppers

These edible prints are great for decorating your own homemade or store-bought treats. We offer various sizes and can customize them too.

See More

Customer Reviews

from 155 reviews
Logo Cookies (6)
Cookies

Great cookies! Love the constructions designs for my son’s birthday party. Thanks again!

Brittany
Logo Cookies (6)
Friends Halloween Cookies (6)
Halloween cookies

I sent these to a friend for his birthday which is around Halloween and he’s a huge Halloween/scary movie fan and he loved them. Not only did they look great, but they tasted great too!

Amanda Wall
Friends Halloween Cookies (6)
Geometric Botanical Cookies (6)
Wedding Rehearsal Cookies

The cookies that were made for the rehearsal party were perfect. They not only matched the decor, fitting right in with everything, they tasted amazing. Thank you Natalie!

Linda T
Geometric Botanical Cookies (6)
Gold Confetti Chocolate Oreos (6)
Outstanding!

These tasty treats not only taste good, but they are mini works of art! Highly recommend.

Catherine Becker Good
Gold Confetti Chocolate Oreos (6)
Photo Cookies (6)
Just Perfect!

The cookies were not only delicious, the photo looked exactly like the original …not to mention the excellent customer service!

Regina Kuhnen
Photo Cookies (6)
Logo Cookies (6)
Spectacular Themed Cookies!

I asked Natalie is she could create a special custom order for a friend's 40th birthday who loves Target. She really over-delivered and these cookies were the talk of the celebration! Thank you Natalie!

Erica Gatlin
Logo Cookies (6)
White Floral Cookies (6)
Wedding Cookies

I ordered the botanical cookies with my daughter and new son-in-law's initials and the date of their wedding. The cookies arrived very timely, were beautiful and tasty too. Everyone enjoyed them, especially the bride and groom!

Cathy Betz
White Floral Cookies (6)
Logo Cookies (6)
Returning customer- LOVE THESE COOKIES!

Natalie is not just an amazing baker but also a very kind human. This is the third time we ordered cookies from here. USPS managed to send our box to LA instead of NYC but Natalie made sure she traced the box and kept in touch with me throughout the whole thing until after we had received the cookies in perfect condition.
She also made sure that the cookies were safe for my baby who is allergic to peanuts.
We absolutely love how beautiful the cookies look! (So far we’ve gotten assorted book covers, personalized tea themed cookies and now Elmo cookies)
We highly highly recommend these cookies to anyone who wants deliciously beautiful and beautifully delicious cookies. Thank you Natalie.

Kruti Suba-Coneti
Logo Cookies (6)
Damask Cross Cookies (6)
Great cookies!

Purchased personalized cookies for my son's baptism. They were both beautiful and delicious!

Kelly Richard
Damask Cross Cookies (6)
Pride Cookie Gift Set
Satisfied Customer

AMAZING PRODUCT! Excellent customer service!

*Unfortunately the order was NEVER received because the USPS delivered it to another resident mail box😡

Stacey Gregory
Pride Cookie Gift Set
White Floral Cookies (6)
Bridal Shower Cookies

Natalie was great to work with! When the guest count for the shower was reduced she switched out the smaller cookies for the larger ones. They arrived in beautiful condition and were delicious. Would highly recommend.

Kathy Sawin
White Floral Cookies (6)
Great cookies!

I had cookies made for my moms 60th birthday and I couldnt have been happier! They came out beautiful and very easy to order also taste amazing!!

Leah Powers
Custom options for Geometric Botanical Cookies (6)
Graduation Logo Cookies (6)
Amazing!

Thank you so much for making my son's Graduation party... just a little sweeter! The cookies were perfect. The design and presentation amazing. Thank you! I will be back sooner than later. Much appreciated.

Ms. O
Graduation Logo Cookies (6)
The cookies were AMAZING

I couldn’t have asked for better service or a better product. The cookies were amazing and the hit of our party. Everyone was asking “where did you get these?!” and “please give me the name of the bakery!” I highly recommend!

Kirsten Flanik
Custom options for School Logo Cookies (6)
Logo Cookies (6)
Perfect!!!!!

Ordered some custom cookies and they turned out great. Toasted delicious and was exactly what we were looking for. Very pleased with the prompt response from questions.

Matthew Malin
Logo Cookies (6)

Merry Go Sweets is a wholly women owned and operated business committed to employing women.

#buywomenowned

Order Merry Go Sweets on EZCater

We are happy to announce that Merry Go Sweets can now be ordered through EZCater.

Order Catering Now